Harry Potter And The Order Of The Phoenix [Spoilers?]

[Abhorsen]

Is that volodarmar guy in all of the books,i dont know cause i havent read any of the books just seen the movies.


Oh and Cucumba,i have done it! It has taken me many moons,but i have finished it! I have constructed my own BAN SABER!!!!(Clicks it on.Nothing.Stands there for a minute.Blinks a couple of times.)

What!Its not working!Maybe I put the batteries in wrong?

 

[Lid]

riiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiight....

back on topic "Book 6 is going to be shorter then book 5, and book 7 will be longer then book 5." wha? where did you get that info from?

 

[DiebytheSword]

She mentioned it in an interview supposedly, she can't be sure till she writes it though, so relax.

In addition, Voldemort is the villian in all of the books save one. But his henchies are all around.

About that ban saber . . .

<-- confiscates it and puts it in a drawer.

 

[Lid]

the bar one is book 3, the villian was Sirius Black

 

[ph34r t3h Cute]

I have a ban saber? Wanna see it?

Back on your own topic ;/

wow, what crawled up your ass and died...

 

[Abhorsen]

Which book would you guys say is the best?


How can you take my Ban Saber? It didnt even work!!Oh well,can i at least have the batteries back? I took them out of my cd player.

 

[DiebytheSword]

wow, what crawled up your ass and died...

a joke you nitwit

Now back on topic you git.

 

[Morrone]

I'd say Book 5 is the best. Second is the 4th and third is the 3rd.

Book 3 would have been better than 4 if it didn't have the huge mistake at the end. How could Harry have saveshimself from the dementors when he hadn't even gone back in time yet? Screwed up the whole plot just to show Harry could make a patronus and find out his father was a stag.

 

[Lid]

Book 3 makes snese... it follows the theory of time travel, read about it. Those 3 hours keep looping for harry

BTW: Book 3 is my favourite

 

[DiebytheSword]

I personally liked Goblet the best . . . Mad Eye Cucumba . . . I like it.

CONSTANT VIGILENCE

 

[Lid]

i like Lupin more, he was down to earth and the worlds nicest guy... but Mad Eye beats him for single collest act by making Malfoy a bouncing Ferret

 

[Death The Jedi]

I also liked Goblet Of Fire better than Order Of The Pheonix, but both were good books. OOP had alot of un-necessary things in it, and that space could have been used to elaborate more on sub-plots, but it was still a good book.

 

[Morrone]

Lid read "The Dementor's Kiss" again. He saves himself before he even went back in time. How did he survive the dementors the first time around? It makes no sense he saves himself with a Patronus he hadn't even made yet. You can't go back in time to save yourself if your dead. Just read the chapter you'll understand.

 

[Lid]

Morrone, it's an infinite loop, ur thinking that THAT Harry is the first, the idea is that time travel is an infinite loop... read about it

 

[Morrone]

Read the chapter please. I'm not talking about the loop. You need to understand what I'm talking about. Before Harry even went back in time he saved himself. It's impossible to go back in time to save yourself because you would be dead before you could go back in time. Yes time travel is an infinite loop but the loop starts somewhere and it could have never began in that situation.

 

[EvaUnit01]

I think OOP was a lot darker than the other baaks, and harry seems more grown up. It tied up a lot of loose ends for me and helped me understand why they introduced (Supposedly) unnecessary characters in the earlier books.
e.g Mrs Figg- would have never guessed what she was.

P.S. on the whole time-travelling issue, its called a temperal paradox(at least thats waht they called it in a movie once) Its not very logical and extremely strange so just dont try to understand it. It just makes that part of the book so much more enjoyable :smile:

 

[Lid]

edit: what eva said

 

[Morrone]

Yea but the blatant error just sucks the fun out of it. He should have blown away all the dementors the first time around but was passing out while doing it so he couldn't see the stag. Then the future Harry could have seen the stag. Thats what should have happened if she wanted it like that.

 

[Lid]

the problem is, she didn't want it like that... she wanted Harry to believe his father was still alive and had rescued him.

 

[Smith|]

I really liked this book aswell, and yes much better than the other 5. The only thing I didnt like is finishing it, I was torn between either reading it or getting closer to the end. I think that Sirius' death was pretty stupid considering he was taunting his oponent and then dieing, but I think it was because he went down that hallway. I guess I have to reread that part again.