your creation process is way too specific. start by sketching a bunch of silouhettes, tiny little stick figures in different poses, just to get an idea of shapes.
then draw bigger ones, maintaining your focus on general shapes.
don't start to look at facial features etc. til right at the end, when you've got a great pose, or design going on. drawing something front and side ortho is not only boring, but it completely destroys anything that could be called "character" in the work.
what defines your character? how can you express his attitude in a blank, front facing image?
why does he have ears? are you a furry? think about that...
i'll use some of my friend MoP's work as an example of how simple little thumbnails can move forward into an amazing (and competition winning) piece of work.
see how there is no set theme, just basic forms in different poses?
and now, the ideas are becoming more refined, but there's still nothing specific at all...
seems to be settling on an idea, but you can tell that it's far from complete, and that major changes can still be applied at any point.
much more refined sketching, and almost a final concept.
finally settled on an idea, and a design.
and there is the final piece!
the general point of my post is this: you wouldn't marry the first girl you ever met, so don't get your head too stuck on your first idea for a character. just doodle, and mess around until it forms itself.