I tend to disagree. Granted the second one is a little too busy, and the first is a little too plain, i really like the first one. (text could use some work, and bg could be a bit better) but other than that they aren't so bad.
lmao. Yep. You should see me on the kai and btl forums. You wouldn't think it was me. But it is. And people hate me for it. But it's fun. ::EDIT:: i mean... um... not... the btl forums... because i was uh.... banned.... yes, banned.... i can't visit those forums anymore.... uh...yeah >.>
And you're right everyone does have their own opinions. But I'm almost positive there is some things he can do to the sigs to make them better to a degree where everyone (or both of us) like them.
Anyway, I don't think he can do anything to really arouse my interest. He'd have to completely remake them. The entire thing just bothers me. As if it was rushed and didn't take that much thought into it. For example, the render blending is pretty bad, and I don't care for the text much.
And I could never imagine that you, Fire Pheonix would get banned.
EDIT : Nevermind about the remaking the signatures. He could just do some more brushing on the backrounds, fix up the text, blend the image a litte, maybe to some pixel patterns and maybe some nifty filters set to overlay. ^^