I definitely have to agree that the brown one is the strongest. The rest just seem like a standard array of stock imagery, preset texture, and blending modes. The brown one is different and has more meaning, though the meaning might be a tiny bit obscure. But I say do things that are a little bit different, don't be afraid to experiment. A lot of people are getting caught in that shapless-blob-with-technical-stuff-sprinkled-on-it trend or the dirty-and-moody-to-no-end trend. Don't follow other people's work, do your own thing.
That said, I think you need to get away from that grid pattern you used in most of them. I'm not sure if it's supposed to simulate pixels or something technical or if it's just space filler. In any case I don't really see the relation to the topic, though to be fair, I don't know what anime your using so I could easily be way off base here. The font is a little wierd for what you're doing as well, part of that is the outline on the text which has a tendency to deform letters a little. If I may suggest, leave the text white and duplicate the layer. Fill the text on the second layer brown or black or whatever dark color fits what you're doing. Apply a gaussian blur or a low-pass to that layer and move it behind the first, white text layer. Generally that creates enough of a separation to be readable and does not affect the text ascenders or descenders like outlines.