I would rate esforces alpha 2 a 7 because half of the models arent finished and there are a lot of bugs. But from looking at the trailer off beta1.....I would give it a 9.98 because it looks almost 100% perfect. Nice Job esf team.
Reason: Models and animations were ugly and some weren't even done!
Rating for what I've seen from the beta - 10
Reason: Awesome graphics higly detailed models, smooth animations, maps and seem a lot bigger because of the scale down and SS_Vegeta did a really awesome job with the sounds especially with the transformations, makes you feel like you're watching an episode of dbz! After watching the trailer it seems REALLY fast so that's my only concern.
Rating after playing the beta - 9 and a 1/2
Reason: Well this is my first post I've made since the beta came out, because I've been playing it so much. Only a couple of problems I've had so far which are db's spawning in a wall, db's getting thrown down the edge of the map on esf_mtside, esf_mid has no textures, esf_rosat is really weird it's just fog spots everywhere and in the show I know for sure it wasn't like that! thats all I can remember but all in all it was worth the wait!
I will give alpha 2.0 a 5.5 and I can't really judge about bet1, cause I haven't played it yet. but from what i've seen it would be an 8. If you just think, half life is a FPS shooter, ESF is so much different.
Well.. I'm not a Beta tester and i haven't played the beta at all yet, but from Mastasurf's trailers and the screen shots i would say that this game is a fast passed, action packed, fighting experience that will rock the world of half-life as we know it..
I give it a 9 - 10, only because the voice clips when you get hurt get enoying and the player tracking in 3rd person view is a little off.. other then those two things it looks great!
I would have this a 9.99, awesome models, good all round gameplay (from beam struggles to melee)! Great job team, for a wonderful job and for putting up with all the pressure from ppl in regards to pre release. The rating 9.99 well is anything perfect?
In regards to being original jrocket, have you ever had an original idea and used sources or ppl with talent to act on it?
I agree with kronik. Even if for some reason you don't like ESF, there are still TONS of other GREAT MODs for Half-Life (Team Fortress Classic, Wizard Wars, Counter-Strike) just to name a few. In my opinion, buying Half-Life was the best 30$ I ever spent in my entire life.