First SIG and AVA, Please Rate

[ESReborn]

I have been messin around in Photoshop for about a year now and a half now.
I'm not the best at it, but I am actually getting much better this year.
So, I decided to make my own little SIG and AVA.

I was trying to go for those blended effects that I see alot.
And the AVA, I didn't really bother with that.
So, I even think it looks like crap! LOL

But, please give me a rating of ?/10.
Thanks.
And Ideas are nice too!

I love making stuff!

SIG

AVATAR

There it is!

 

[Viki@killer]

Signature:7/10 Why:
Good cutout:3/10
Good shading:4/10
No background:minus 3/10

Avatar:5/10 Why:
Background,but only yellow-me bad:1/10
1 charachter,good seeable:2/10
The pen aura around Vegeta:1/10
Majin Vegeta,mmmm,me likes :laff: :1/10
Bad cutout(I copied picture on my computer,high zoom,very bad...):3/10
No shading:2/10
(my avatar is real!!!My dog on ours sofa,his son is left to him,doesn't see on that picture...)
Good sig job for n00b,avatar is not good,as u see....

 

[Chosen Saiyan]

i think they both looks very good


Annnnnnnnddd tatatatatadatadatadatatatatatadatadatadatatatatatadatadatadatatatatatadatadatadatatatatatadatadatadatatatatatadatadatadatatatatatadatadatadatatatatatadatadatadatatatatatadatadatadatatatatatadatadatadatatatata

congratulations.... to me!!!
100TH POST REACHED

 

[ESReborn]

?
I have no idea what you meant by all that?
How were you grading it?
1 being the highest?
10 being the highest?

10/10 is the highest
1/10 is the lowest.

So what exactly are you talking about?
Besides, you can't say that I don't have a good cutout, look at your Goku...
And my avatar, you're not suppose to download and then zoom in.

That's the same with any picture. Are you new at this or something?

Don't criticize me if you don't know what you're talking about.

 

[Amitron]

Hmmm lol i think you just overreacted a bit there buddy, no reason to get pissed at viki. He grades it by giving each indivdual uhh aspect of your sig or whatever like a 5/10 or a 6/10 or something like that...yea im not all that sure, and then he adds it up to give you a total score outa 10 10/10 being the highest..

 

[MinesSkylineR34]

congratulations.... to me!!!
100TH POST REACHED

posting in signatures doesnt count...

the sig...
nice for a first, id stick to one character instead of making a collage, just start doing backgrounds avatar's too simple, just take a section out of the sig for that stuff
the inner gradiant on the text, i dont really like that part either and give it a border
other than that...thats a good start

 

[Judge]

It reminds me a lot of the signatures I used to make, you used high-quality pics. you are blending in nicely. I think if you experiment and practice with it more, you can become a lot better. cuz its nicely done imo.

its just a bit big, and I personally dont like big sigs, so I would shrink it down a bit

 

[ESReborn]

Alright...
Thanks for the tip guys, and sorry viki didn't mean to jump on ya.

I'll see what I can do on the next one...

 

[Cruzharo]

Hey the sig looks exelent but the avater sux...

 

[ESReborn]

Well, I have another thread with the two new sigs...
Here it is.

New SIGs

That is the new sigs...