Sig You Dig?

MF29 · Sep 16, 2006

How is this sig, I want your honest opinion, sugar coating not aloud. And that does not mean post only bad opinions.

Synth · Sep 16, 2006

Well for one, that vulgarity isn't allowed, so remove that asap.

MF29 · Sep 16, 2006

Synth said:
Well for one, that vulgarity isn't allowed, so remove that asap.

OHHH, I forgot, Im about to get busted.

Super Veggeto · Sep 16, 2006

Green is not your color too =P

kenny-DK · Sep 16, 2006

I think it's realy good.. But it's to green!

Adaptus · Sep 16, 2006

It's pretty cool, but it's way too green, IMO. x:

Kaination · Sep 16, 2006

Hmm.

Could use a little work. There is, indeed, a lot of green. The face looks cartoony, while the rest looks real.

Also, you're finally using better text. I'd say maybe the render isnt good, but something about it doesn't make it flare up at me like OMG!~

7/10

You're definately getting better.

MF29 · Sep 17, 2006

Thanks for the crits guys.

Jehuty187 · Sep 17, 2006

The text is bad, it is WAY too green, the render is low quality, and the border doesn't even cover the whole thing. 3/10. Sorry, but you said no sugar coating.

MF29 · Sep 17, 2006

Saying sorry isn't nessecary, Getting good or bad crits is good, Now I know what I need to get better on, If you guys sugar coated, I would be walking around thinking my sigs rule and that I don't need to improve.

Jakut · Sep 17, 2006

The gokus image is bad quality, the text is bad, the border is bad and the bg dosnt quite fit in with the stock.

Overall 3/10

That honest enough?

MF29 · Sep 17, 2006

Being honest is good enough for me.

PiXel · Sep 17, 2006

maybe try to put brushes over a stock, also give more colors and contrast. give some more simpel style to your sigs.

for now i can say that you have a better font ad you placed maybe the stock into the right place but its all coming, keep up.

Dokutayuu · Sep 17, 2006

5/10 Nice but way too green. I've always considered you as a blue person anyway.

MF29 · Sep 17, 2006

How is the sig that I am currently using.

Jariroth · Sep 17, 2006

It's not too good quality, i can actually see the pixels. Is it ripped from a arcade game version? And why does it have to have that colour overlay.
Well its better than the green goku, i guess. 5/10

MF29 · Sep 17, 2006

It's from a SNES game.

Mccdbz5 · Sep 19, 2006

I think the Goku one is a lot better. The one you're using now, I think picture is too low quality, but the background is cool. Try putting a different image in that background, and I think you'll have a pretty good signature.

Ryeko · Sep 19, 2006

The one your using now is much better. But your current one has a low quality render. The goku one is ****ed up. You chose the most random color. You need to get a better font, fix your border. Border should be the top most layer, in most situations. The render seems a litle bit, low quality, though it may not be. The background on the Goku one is good though.

MF29 · Sep 19, 2006

Ryeko said:
The one your using now is much better. But your current one has a low quality render. The goku one is ****ed up. You chose the most random color. You need to get a better font, fix your border. Border should be the top most layer, in most situations. The render seems a litle bit, low quality, though it may not be. The background on the Goku one is good though.

Your exactly right, I chose the random "green" vibe because I was so frustrated and could not find anything to match with the render.

Sig You Dig?

New Member

brainfeeder

New Member

2D/3D Artist

New Member

New Member

New Member

New Member

New Member

New Member

New Member

New Member

Active Member

Now with Kung-Fu action!

New Member

New Member

New Member

New Member

New Member

New Member

Users who are viewing this thread