well.. it doesn't look good to me, then again , your new to it, and u don't use a top notch program to make sigs withpersonally, I think pixelart fits mspaint a lot better, and u can make some beautyfull things with that. Critting the sigs the cut-out is what kills is I think (on the 2nd and 3th) and on the first the pic looks reallly bad quallity... I think this is because of paint though..
It's hard to crit something made with paint, I know how hard it is to make something look good with it. Also the effects u can create are very limited with it ..., good luck with ur next sigs if u have the possibility u might want to try and switch to another program :yes:
grtz Naz