Graphics card question

Killface · Mar 4, 2005

Hey guys. I want to buy a new video card but i dont know whether i should get a 128mb card pr spring for a 256mb card. Which one should i get? and if i get the 128mb one will i be okay for the next 3 or 4 years or will it be outdated and then i have to go get a new 256mb card?
Please help, thanks.

Ravendust · Mar 4, 2005

I imagine in 4 years we'll see 512 or even 1024 (1gb) cards so anything you buy now could be outdated by then. I'd go for the 256 because the 128 will be outdated a lot faster. I reccomend the ATI Radeon X800XT 256mb, although I have a 9800XT which isn't as good, i've heard nothing but good things.

Link: http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProductDesc.asp?description=14-127-138R&depa=0

Smith| · Mar 5, 2005

Well, for serious gaming (High Res with AA and AF), 256MB cards are a must. If you're just a light gamer, then 128MB cards should do you fine. But don't buy a card that can't handle that large of a frame buffer, like a 5200. If you're going 256MB, then get atleast a 6800 or X800Pro. Memory on lesser cards is pretty much useless when it reaches > 128MB as the core itself just can't handle the amount of stress to actually render the screen with such high quality.

Killface · Mar 6, 2005

I can only get a PCI card for now. Im not going to upgrade my motherboard to agp or PCI express until Christmas because of my warranty on my computer and i want a card now. What do you guys think of these cards?
Click Here andHere , I think they are pretty good for being pci cards.

Smith| · Mar 7, 2005

You are overpaying for either of those cards. Also, don't even go 128MB if you're going PCI. Just get a 9200 64MB crap. Anything on the PCI bus is too limited to be of use.

Killface · Mar 7, 2005

Yeah but wont they get the job done or what? all I care about for now is that I get a good card that gets the job done. Whats up with PCI anyway, why does everyone say that its crappy, and what makes it so slow?

Tassadar · Mar 9, 2005

Smith or Cuc could probably tell you more about it, but the bottom line is that PCI slots are old and outdated, and are no longer meant for graphics cards. PCI slots are a lot slower than AGP (hence the name, Accelerated Graphics Port).

Wikipedia said:
AGP
AGP 4x, using a 32-bit channel operating at 133 MHz double pumped to an effective 266 MHz resulting in a maximum data rate of 1066 megabytes per second; 1.5 V signaling;
AGP 8x, double pumped at 266 MHz to give a maximum of 2133 megabytes per second; 0.8 V signaling.
PCI (non-Express)
33.33 MHz clock with synchronous transfers
peak transfer rate of 133MB per second
32-bit or 64-bit bus width
PCI 2.2 allows for 66MHz signalling (requires 3.3 volt signalling) (peak transfer 533 MB/s)

So, as you see... PCI is just old and crappy. The first PCI was made in 1990, and the first AGP in 1997. A new type of PCI slot, called PCI-X, or PCI Express, has come out recently and put PCI slots back on the map for graphics cards, but don't confuse PCI cards with PCI-X cards or visa versa, as they are quite different performance wise. And you'll also need to invest in a nForce 4 mobo with PCI-X and a new 64 bit processor if you want to effectively go to PCI-X .

And that's my 2 cents.

Iyce Da Kidd · Mar 10, 2005

since it's a graphic card question... can you add anti-antialiasing (pixel shader) to a video card that does not have it?

Smith| · Mar 12, 2005

Ice Man said:
since it's a graphic card question... can you add anti-antialiasing (pixel shader) to a video card that does not have it?

HAH. That was probably one of the funniest tech things I've ever heard. Some forums I visit would have you crucified for that line.

Oh, and Tassadar, PCI-Express is PCI-E, not PCI-X. Just though you'd like to know >_o.

Yeah but wont they get the job done or what? all I care about for now is that I get a good card that gets the job done. Whats up with PCI anyway, why does everyone say that its crappy, and what makes it so slow?
Reply With Quote

Yea, pretty much what Tassy said was right. PCI is a lot older and cannot deliver nearly enough bandwidth for a graphic's card. AGP and PCI-E are the latest and greatest things, but PCI-E is a little overboard and not needed... yet.

Iyce Da Kidd · Mar 12, 2005

Dork said:
HAH. That was probably one of the funniest tech things I've ever heard. Some forums I visit would have you crucified for that line.

Well everyone doesn't know about computers like you do -_-, It was a question, I didn't ask for your remarks did I?

Smith| · Mar 12, 2005

It wasn't an insult, I just thought it was kind of funny. Sheesh. Sorry, Iceman.

But yea, I'll go into depth for you:
Antialiasing is a render method that allows you to "blur" the edges of structures ingame, such as a wall or a gun to make it blend in with the surroundings and remove the "jaggies".

Pixel shading is a processing feature of the latest GPUs (Graphics Processing Units) or VPUs (Video Processing Unit), as told by ATI. It allows the GPU to be programmed to "shade" pixels and form complex effects such as bump mapping and the Half Life 2 water. It's a very useful feature

.

I hope I kept the simple, usually when I do this it ends up being confusing as I can't find the right words in my head.

Iyce Da Kidd · Mar 12, 2005

Ice: I luv you
Smith: I luv you too

Smith:... KIss Me

Ice: Ok..

*WOOOSH*

lol Iz sowweh! and danke

Killface · Mar 14, 2005

Will PCI lag too bad or will I be okay for a while until i get a new PCIe motherboard and a PCIe card? because all I care about is that I get a card that will get the job done, kinda like a temporary card for the next year or so, and i can only get a PCI card, if i didnt already tell you guys.

Smith| · Mar 14, 2005

Depends what you plan on playing. If you stick to Half Life 1 mods, you'll be perfectly fine. But don't plan on playing any of the newest games at ... 15 fps.

DiebytheSword · Mar 14, 2005

And if you upgrade, don't upgrade to an AGP mobo, get a mobo with PCI-E . . . AGP uses direct traces to the "northbridge" area of the chipset, and is physically closer to the CPU, but PCI-E has much greater bandwidth. Remember, AGP is overglorified PCI with direct traces, all further versions of AGP (3.0 is the current standard) are built on the same limitations with greater bandwidth. PCI-E is designed primarily to replace the PCI spec but replacing AGP was kept in mind.

Think of it this way. PCI was the defacto standard since the pentium 1, all the original graphic accellerator cards used it. When the need for bandwidth outstripped PCI's abilities, they made a band-aid called AGP. AGP worked for a while, but it is still a band-aid. PCI-E is an overhaul of the whole bus system which hosted both PCI and it's bastard offspring AGP.

Any, and I mean ANY, of your upgrade options must include PCI-E or you will only replace your mobo again. Upgrading your PCI card will be useless.

Smith| · Mar 14, 2005

Cucumba said:
And if you upgrade, don't upgrade to an AGP mobo, get a mobo with PCI-E . . . AGP uses direct traces to the "northbridge" area of the chipset, and is physically closer to the CPU, but PCI-E has much greater bandwidth. Remember, AGP is overglorified PCI with direct traces, all further versions of AGP (3.0 is the current standard) are built on the same limitations with greater bandwidth. PCI-E is designed primarily to replace the PCI spec but replacing AGP was kept in mind.

Think of it this way. PCI was the defacto standard since the pentium 1, all the original graphic accellerator cards used it. When the need for bandwidth outstripped PCI's abilities, they made a band-aid called AGP. AGP worked for a while, but it is still a band-aid. PCI-E is an overhaul of the whole bus system which hosted both PCI and it's bastard offspring AGP.

Any, and I mean ANY, of your upgrade options must include PCI-E or you will only replace your mobo again. Upgrading your PCI card will be useless.

While yea, it's good to be future proof, PCI-E offers no performance boosts over AGP8X even with it's "super" bandwidth. The only thing I could think that PCI-E gives which is a good bonus is the extra voltage so you don't have to use as many, if any at all, molex connectors on the card.

Killface · Mar 15, 2005

Will I be okay Playing Halo and Farcry and those types of games, or are they too demanding? And if not, then should I just buy a new motherboard with PCIe instead? Because thats what im leaning toward right now.

Smith| · Mar 15, 2005

Don't expecting much.

DiebytheSword · Mar 16, 2005

crashmann64 said:
Will I be okay Playing Halo and Farcry and those types of games, or are they too demanding? And if not, then should I just buy a new motherboard with PCIe instead? Because thats what im leaning toward right now.

You might squeak by with Halo, but Farcry will be out of your reach.

Devion · Mar 16, 2005

There are some advantages of pci-e.

Like the TurboCache(nVidia) and HyperMemory(ATI), which werent possible with AGP.

Graphics card question

New Member

New Member

New Member

New Member

New Member

New Member

New Member

New Member

New Member

New Member

New Member

New Member

New Member

New Member

Live free or die by the sword

New Member

New Member

New Member

Live free or die by the sword

G-Bear

Users who are viewing this thread